Basement utility room with a water heater, exposed pipes, and an electrical panel.

How Old Is Too Old for a Water Heater When You Buy a Pittsburgh House?

Aubre J. Stacknick is a Global Real Estate Advisor with Piatt Sotheby's International Realty in Pittsburgh, PA, helping buyers and sellers across Western Pennsylvania see a home through a builder's eyes. I am not a licensed plumber, and this is general information. A licensed plumber can tell you the condition of a specific unit.

How long does a water heater last?

DOE's Energy Saver guide says most storage water heaters last 10 to 15 years, while tankless water heaters can last more than 20 years. Those are general ranges, not guarantees. A well-kept unit can outlast the range and a neglected one can fall short of it.

Water quality, how hard the unit works and how often it was serviced all affect the real number. That is why I never judge a water heater by age alone. I look at what is around it, too.

How do you find out how old a water heater is?

Look for the data plate on the tank. It usually lists a serial number, the model and the capacity. The manufacturer's website, or a licensed plumber, can tell you how to read the serial number to find the manufacture date. Different brands code the date differently, so I do not guess.

Ask the seller when it was installed and whether there is a receipt, warranty or service record. If the house is new construction, the builder's warranty may cover it. I covered that in What Does a Builder's Warranty Cover on a New Construction Home, and What Does It Not?

What should you check at a showing?

Take two minutes in the basement or utility area. I look for:

  • Rust or water staining on the tank, at the base or around the pipe connections
  • Water on the floor, or a stain on the floor where a leak has dried
  • Corrosion at the pipe fittings
  • A discharge pipe at the pressure relief valve that is present and runs down to a safe place
  • Scorch marks, soot or a rusty flue on a gas unit
  • A tank sitting directly on a finished floor with no way for a leak to drain away
  • Unusual noises, such as rumbling or popping, if you can run hot water for a moment

None of these proves the tank is failing. A rusty base is a good reason to ask a plumber to look. A tank that leaks does not get repaired, it gets replaced. If the unit is in a finished space, think about where the water will go when it does fail.

Why does the water temperature matter?

DOE says to set a water heater to 120 degrees Fahrenheit, a temperature considered safe for most of the population. If you buy a house, check the setting. If you are selling, check it before showings. Water that is too hot is a safety concern and wastes energy, and the setting is easy to check.

What does regular care look like?

DOE's guide suggests draining a quart of water from the tank every three months to remove sediment that impedes heat transfer and lowers efficiency. Ask the seller whether anyone has done that, but do not expect a clear answer. Many owners have never heard of it. If you do it yourself, follow the manufacturer's instructions, or ask a plumber to show you.

What are the options when a water heater needs replacement?

DOE describes several types: conventional storage, tankless or on-demand, heat pump and solar water heaters. It recommends looking for the ENERGY STAR and EnergyGuide labels when you choose a new one, and says a more efficient unit can cost more up front, but the energy savings continue for the lifetime of the appliance.

I would not choose a type from a blog. Ask a licensed plumber what fits your house: the fuel, the venting, the space and the number of people who use hot water. Get a written quote that says what is included, such as the old unit's removal, new valves, venting and any permit. If the unit is in a basement with a finished ceiling above it, ask how the work will be done without damaging the ceiling.

What should you do if you are buying a house with an old water heater?

Do not panic and do not ignore it. Here is what I would do:

1. Ask the seller for the install date and any paperwork.

2. Ask your inspector to note the age, the condition and the safety valve.

3. If the unit is near or past the 10 to 15 year range, treat replacement as a near-term cost and put an estimate in your budget.

4. If you see rust, leaks or corrosion, ask a licensed plumber to look before your contingency period ends.

5. Talk with your agent about whether the finding changes the negotiation. An aging but working unit is usually a budget item, not a deal breaker.

If you are checking the whole mechanical picture, add How Old Is Too Old for a Furnace or Boiler When You Buy a Pittsburgh House? to the list. For how I walk a house from foundation to roof, see the Builder's Eye approach.

What should sellers do before listing?

Check the temperature setting. Look for rust, leaks and corrosion. Gather the install date, receipts and warranty. If the unit is old and showing wear, decide whether to replace it or to disclose its age and condition and let the buyer's inspector confirm it. A pre-listing look can help you decide. See What Does a Pre-Listing Inspection Catch Before Buyers Do?

A replaced water heater is not a big selling point on its own, but a leaking one can reduce a buyer's trust in the whole house. If the unit is working and in decent shape, do not replace it only because it is old.

What are the common mistakes?

  • Judging a water heater by age alone and ignoring condition
  • Not asking for the install date and paperwork
  • Ignoring rust at the base because the tank is still working
  • Leaving the temperature too high
  • Not checking where the water will go if the tank leaks
  • Planning to replace a water heater without a written quote

FAQ

How long does a water heater last?

DOE says most storage water heaters last 10 to 15 years, while tankless water heaters can last more than 20 years.

What temperature should a water heater be set to?

DOE says to set it to 120 degrees Fahrenheit, a temperature considered safe for most of the population.

How do you tell how old a water heater is?

Check the data plate on the tank for a serial number and ask the manufacturer or a licensed plumber how to read it. Ask the seller for installation records.

Should you buy a house with an old water heater?

Yes, if you budget for replacement and the unit shows no leaks or corrosion. Ask a licensed plumber to look at any rust or leaking.

If you are buying or selling and want a builder's read on the mechanical systems, book a 30-minute call. Bring the address and the inspection report.

Work with Aubre

Knowledge Starts with Knowing®. As your Trusted Real Estate Sherpa™, I look beyond the pretty, using 20 years of building and renovating homes to show you what a listing photo can't. It's why a client who has bought and sold more than 50 properties calls me his family's real estate professional.
Follow Me